Hello Everybody!
“How Do I Improve the Performance of my Female Campaigns??” Funny you should ask…
Many of our advertisers often press me for tips on how to capture the ever-elusive female demographic. We notoriously click less than our male counterparts, but tend to convert better. This leaves a window of opportunity that remains largely untapped by our advertisers. This is where I come in. It’s time for this male dominated industry to gain some insight on what ads will work for women, from a woman.
Having worked on the ad approval side of POF for over a year, I have seen the majority of creatives and campaigns that have passed through our platform. So, despite being just one woman, hopefully my experience and perspective as a female will inspire you to try some new angles when catering ads to the fairer sex.
My tips are as follows:
1. Personalize my experience. The core of Plentyoffish is about creating connections between people, so an advertisement should make an immediate emotional impression. While an ad that screams “MEN LOOKING FOR SINGLE MOMS” could be interpreted as blunt, insensitive, or even predatory, an ad that reads, “THESE GUYS LOVE KIDS,” will probably not be interpreted the same way. Even a small amount of positive emotional weight can take a user from feeling like she is being blatantly singled out, to feeling like she is pursuing the opportunity to make a connection with a real person on her own terms. The same idea goes for images. A guy wearing sunglasses and hiding his eyes may suggest emotional unavailability, while a guy giving me an inquisitive look, a playful smile, or an eyebrow raise means he wants to connect with me.
2. Give me choices. Variety is the spice of life, so make sure you are providing it for our female users. Pose a question, and give her the option to answer it, because chances are she will – with a click. EX/ “WANT A MAN WHO WILL TAKE YOU SHOPPING?” is worded in a way that puts the power and the choice in the users hands. Also be sure to split test and rotate your images to remain competitive. You never know what small subtlety in a photo will prove to be the next big thing, so cover all of your bases. Guys with shaved heads and tattoos for women who like the bad boys, and athletes standing with trophies, or college grads with their diplomas for women who are seeking achievers and providers.
3. Make me feel important. Every woman likes to feel like she is getting an exclusive deal or scoop on something, and we are nosy social creatures. I will admit that I visit a handful of celebrity and gossip websites daily, and part of the intrigue is the impression that I am privy to private information. Write your ads in a way that conveys urgency and exclusivity to our user. EX/ “SPOTTED: WE FOUND SOMEONE TO SPOIL YOU.” To support this angle with your images, look for candid looking photos that will peak her curiosity to capture the click. We do not allow celebrity images to appear in our advertisements, so find some amateur photos of guys that look as though they could have been snapped by the paparazzi!
I will add 3 more tips on the blog next week, so stay tuned! In the meantime I have also included some research conducted by Web Ad.Vantage about the advertising experience for a woman. No huge surprises, but it really reiterates the importance for strong images and ad text that speaks to the user.



For any feedback or further questions you have about female reaction to any specific ads or campaigns, you can contact me directly at Shannon@pof.com

8 comments
Comments feed for this article
September 6, 2011 at 7:29 pm
Steve
Hey Shannon that’s a great post, it was well written and it’s nice to hear a female perspective. Ben has been really helpful but it’s great to hear what you have to say too.
September 6, 2011 at 7:43 pm
Chris
Great stuff Shannon… be very interested to hear your thoughts in a future post about what you think about women clicking on images of women… does that inquisitive (weighing up the competition) side outweigh the hunk in the sunglasses??
September 6, 2011 at 8:05 pm
grahamnichols
Great to hear from a real woman’s viewpoint Shannon.
Ben in drag just wasn’t cutting it. LOL. (nice shoes though)
September 6, 2011 at 10:31 pm
3dolladotcom
Thanks for this Shannon, linkback coming at ya from 3dolla!
September 7, 2011 at 1:34 pm
Tom
Shannon, this is a great post. Thank You for your input
September 8, 2011 at 12:38 am
Andrew
Great insight here, good to get a (hot) women’s perspective on the matter. I think us men are a bit too narrow minded and think that women are going to respond to pictures of ripped-men and titles stating “SINGLES WANTED JOIN FREE” will cut it.
Looking forward to the next post
September 8, 2011 at 3:13 am
seth
Not sure if I agree that “MEN LOOKING FOR SINGLE MOMS” would do any better than something less open to interpretation, such as “THESE GUYS LOVE KIDS.” (With that title couldn’t a woman think the men are pedophiles lol – sorry, but you see how I could extend your argument). The only problem with the first that is very clear is that it is so generic. Did you split test it? Maybe for part II you could actually test out some ad copies and show us some science behind your ideas. Proof is in the CTRs
Intriguing article though, and looking forward to part deux.
September 13, 2011 at 4:07 pm
John
i’m guessing here, but since Shannon works for POF, she knows the CTRs and what converts, and is adding in her personal experiences to corroborate the suggestions?